Mega Man Legacy Collection – The Games Ranked

Megaman Legacy CollectionTaking a little break from what’s been a pretty Destiny heavy couple weeks lately, I wanted to put down my ranking of the six games that are present in the Mega Man Legacy Collection. I already talked a bit about the game as a whole, and in the past I’ve talked about the classic series as well. But now that those first six NES games are easily available on current-gen systems, I thought maybe people would like to know which are the better games in the collection.

Mega Man 3 Title Screen

We’ll start with what I think is the very best Mega Man classic game – Mega Man III. it has the first example of story shakeup, with the Doc Robot stages, Break Man’s presence and the two Dr.s working together. Add in the best play control seen in the series to that point, and really the foundation for the 8-bit games moving forward. Rush opens up all kinds of different movement options, making for some pretty clever platforming. It’s also got one of the better sets of Robot Masters, with great music to go with them. I know Mega Man 2 gets a ton of talk about being the best – but I think the series really started to shine with the third game. Play them both back-to-back and I think you’ll start to come around.

Mega Man 4 Title Screen

Next up, I think the next level actually is a tie. I would put Mega Man 2 and Mega Man 4 together, but for different reasons. MM4 is my very favorite game in the series, mainly for nostalgic and personal reasons, but I do think it stands up there pretty close to the top. It’s got that same level of player control – which gives the player incredible precision, which then extends to awesome platforming sections. Rush is still in there, and then they added in the two items to increase the options. I do think that the Robot Masters are also awesome. MM4 is also the first game to add in a second castle section with Dr. Cossack, and really added in a little bit of depth to the story. Mega Man 2 on the other hand is up there for a different set of reasons. It’s the first one that truly feels special – the original had a great start, but the sequel is when the series really takes hold. The precision is stepped up, the detail in the levels is increased, the Robot Masters are a bit more inventive and there’s more variety in weapons available to the player. Not only that but the game has perhaps two of the most recognizable pieces of music in the series and it’s really hard to argue against Mega Man 2‘s place on the pedestal.

Mega Man 2 Title Screen

Next up on the list, just missing the podium, is another set of two games that I think are pretty comparable. Just like the last set, I think it’s a different set of reasons that keep them pretty close: Mega Man 5 and Mega Man. The original needs to be here, for historical reasons mainly. It’s the beginning of the franchise, which keeps it from being the worst out there. Yes, it’s probably the hardest in the collection, mainly because of the lack of E-Tanks and passwords. Yes it has only six Robot Masters and a pretty simple set of them to boot. But looking at it within the context of the collection it’s hard to say it’s the worst Mega Man game. With MM5 though, I think we hit that point where Capcom ran into a bit of a wall. The story is very similar to the previous game – a first boss that is a red herring, complete with a whole castle to fight through. The actual play control is still at that same level, nothing really changes from Mega Man 4 onward. I think the Robot Masters are a real mixed bag in MM5 though – there are some cool ones, but there’s also some kinda lame ones. Music that is mediocre in its arrangement also doesn’t help. MM5 is really where the series started to show its age – five games in just a few years is pretty rough. That’s why I think the Mega Man X series really came in at the perfect time.

Which brings us, of course, to the final game in the collection – Mega Man 6. While it’s not a bad game, per se, but when you compare it with the other games it really struggles to stand out. Losing Rush’s separate forms in exchange for the power adapters really I think was a poor move. The storyline is the third time in a row that there’s a doppelganger villain before Dr. Wily is revealed to be behind it all – complete with two castles to deal with. What I think really hurts MM6 is that a lot of the Robot Masters feel boring. There are a few that feel like retreads of previous themes, and other that just don’t really come across as exciting to fight. Mega Man 6 wasn’t actually made by Capcom, and it shows – it was a Nintendo made game. Again, it isn’t a bad game – but I think once you’ve played through all the games in the Legacy Collection, you’ll agree it’s probably the weakest one in there.

Advertisements

Minecraft Monday: A Simple Project at Last

Mega Man 2 American BoxIt’s a funny thing – when I started this project, it was originally just going to be Pharoah Man; he’s my favorite Robot Master after all. When it ended up being easy enough to do though and I decided to create the whole “love letter to Mega Man” project, I was in a bit of a weird situation. I had started not at the beginning, but right in the middle of the series. Since then I’ve gone backward in the franchise, which has given me a pretty unique view of the design process with the Stage Select and Title Screens. That perspective is super apparent now that I’m working on Mega Man 2.

 

Megaman 2 Stage SelectLet’s start with the Stage Select screen, since it’s the part I just wrapped up with. Mega Man 3, as I mentioned in my updates while I was working on that screen, has a ton of detail in there. The portrait frames are pretty complicated – the lights on the corners are actually bulged out, so it’s not a perfect square. That makes it a little more complicated to go through them. In Mega Man 2 the portraits are just simple squares – 45×45 pixels. The lights for the corners are simple squares too. The design is much more simple too – just full bars of colors – compared with Mega Man 3, which had a lot more detail in the bars. The field aside from the portraits is also much more simpler – just a few bars of color in Mega Man 2, compared with the “Mega Man III” that repeats all throughout the field. So after spending a couple weeks working on Mega Man 3, I have been very happy to see the simpler design. The Robot Masters have actually been pretty simple too – the color scheme is much less involved – with each bot really only using a couple colors. The problem comes from Bubble Man – his green colors don’t quite match up. I’m alright with the final result, but it’s definitely not perfect. The only really other issue was with Quick Man – his boomerang actually breaks through the portrait, so it took a little double checking to get it down.

Mega Man 2 Title Screen

As for the Title Screen – unlike Mega Man 3, which I think is pretty much the peak of the early games complexity in Stage Select; Mega Man 2 is the peak in the early games complexity on Title Screens. With the building, Mega Man himself, plus the whole logo, there’s a lot going on. They went the total opposite on Mega Man 3 – it’s a full black screen after all. After that they decided to add in just a few little bits of details to give it a bit more energy. I’m actually pretty excited to see how it ends up with the color palette that Minecraft has.

Minecraft Monday: Mega Man 3 Finally Finished With, Progress Continues On

Mega Man 3 Box ArtWhen I started this whole project, I knew that this was going to be a huge undertaking. Six NES games to do, plus two more 8-bit styled ones in Mega Man 9 and 10 – not to mention the possibility of doing the fan-made 8-bit de-makes of Mega Man 7 and 8. That’s a whole hell of a lot of Minecrafting to do. What I didn’t expect was that Mega Man 3 – the second game I tackled – would be so damn frustrating. I already have mentioned my continual messing up while doing the Title Screen, and also found another small error I had made in the Stage Select. Thankfully, it was only two blocks that needed to be fixed, so it didn’t mess up much. I only even found it because I was going overly detailed with one of the new additions to the sprite field. I decided to put in Break Man (Proto Man)’s portrait in, which was actually pretty cool, thanks to his scarf breaking out of the border. I did something similar with Dr. Cossack in Mega Man 4, but since Break Man is actually named like the other Robot Masters, I put his name below the portrait too. Of course that meant applying the background too – I made sure that the placement of the “Mega Man III” matches up with the center portrait on the screen. That’s where I found my error – I had messed up on the “M” in Man on a couple in the screen.

Megaman 3 Stage Select

Once that was dealt with though, I had a bunch of blank space to fill in with the sprite field. After digging around for a good sheet of Rush, I was able to put in Rush with Coil and Jet in there, along with all of the weapon energy and health energy pick ups. I got a little lucky there, in that there was just enough space for each pick up. While I was in pick up mode, I finished up the buffer zone between games, carpeted the whole thing, and called Mega Man 3 completed.

Megaman 2 Stage Select

I was still feeling the Minecraft though, so I went ahead and moved on to Mega Man 2. I set up four stacks of 64 blue wool, switched to survival, and set up the bottom row of 256 for the Stage Select. The thing with Mega Man 2 is that the Stage Select is a lot more sparse than Mega Man 3 – there’s not much going on, so to get started there was some counting of pixel rows. Moving back a game also adds in another little detail – for each Robot Masters’ name, in the later games, the white pixels are bordered with a row of black to add some depth. That row of black doesn’t exist in Mega Man 2, so the letters look a little weird right now. Since I was on a roll, I went ahead and finished up Metal Man and Flash Man – both were pretty easy to do, although Metal Man isn’t quite an exact match. The early Mega Man games use what is basically a really dark magenta color for deep red – which doesn’t exist in Minecraft, so I just used red wool and pink clay, like I have for the rest of the red Robot Masters. All in all, the Stage Select should go pretty smooth, it’s the Title Screen I’m looking at – there’s a lot more going on with it than any other one.

Minecraft Monday: Mega Man 3 Sprites Completed, Buffer Zone in Progress

I shared last week how I went about tackling the Robot Master sprites for Mega Man 3. Much like with those sprites, I took a little different approach to the Mega Man sprites with the weapons. With Mega Man 4, they were all bundled up together into one set – which looks alright with the fences I use for dividing and orientation removed. With this set though, I wanted to take a little more organized approach, hence my breaking the Mega Man sprites out into a separate section. In order to keep everything on one level, my plan was to put a standing sprite of Mega Man (with one exception), and the weapon’s sprite below him, followed by the menu icon. Aside from Top Spin, the plan worked pretty well – there’s a little variation, thanks to the fact that some weapons have big sprites – Spark Shock and Shadow Blade – while others are really quite thin – Gemini Laser and Needle Cannon.

So the organization worked out pretty well, but there were a couple other little things that still rub me wrong a little. First is Top Spin. As a Mega Man fan, it’s a crap weapon – I only think people use it to kill Shadow Man, and that’s it. It’s unreliable with its energy usage, and on top of that, it’s a melee weapon that requires you to spin into enemies with – and you can only use it while jumping. From a Minecraft pixel art perspective though, it’s even more annoying. One of the two colors for Mega Man’s armor is easy to match – the grey on his legs, hands and helmets. The problem is with the highlight color. According to the game artwork – it’s supposed to be a yellowish color:
Top Spin ArtHowever, the in-game sprite coloring looks a bit different. That yellow, which would be no problem replicating in Minecraft, isn’t in the sprite:Top Spin Sprite

Instead, that looks a lot like a pinkish-grey color. And while there is is a pink wool, and even pink clay, both have too much red in them to really act as an analog. So I ended up using the pink clay, but I’m not super happy with out it turned out. If there’s an update down the road that offers a better option, this is definitely one detail that I’ll go back and change. The other issue was also with Top Spin. It doesn’t actually have a weapon sprite – when you fire it in mid-air, you spin around a whole bunch – that’s the attack. So I used the jumping sprite for Mega Man, but instead of also using the crappy pink color for the spin lines, I just decided to forgo them completely. So Top Spin is a little off compared with the rest of the Mega Men.

Once I had finished up the Mega Man work, I decided to look at the buffer zone between Mega Man 4 and Mega Man 3. I had originally planned on putting in various sprites of Mega Man, Proto Man, Rush and even Robot Masters that I liked. What I instead went with was a repeating pattern of the 1-Up power-up (Mega Man’s Head) and the E-Tank pick-up. I had left a bit too much space horizontally, so when I go ahead on to Mega Man 2, I know to leave a bit less, to give me a nice even split. I think 20 blocks will let me have two free spaces on either side of the widest parts of the sprites. But the nice thing is that with the white carpet placed down after, it looks pretty good. It’s certainly better than just having blank space – it gives a bit of a feeling like wallpaper to me.

Which brings me to my plan of attack for this week. I still have a bunch of free space in the sprite field, so much like I did with Mega Man 4, I’m going to add in an extra portrait. Instead of making the one for Wily, which would go with theme, I think I’ll do Break Man (Proto Man) and if there’s still space enough, I will do one of the busted ones from the Doc Robot phase. After that’s handled, I need to extend down the buffer pieces down to the sprites, carpet it, and then it’s on to Mega Man 2. I would say I’m probably only a couple hours away from moving on, which I can’t wait. Mega Man 3 definitely has been a much more complicated project than Mega Man 4 was. I don’t expect Mega Man 2 to be that rough, but I will be making sure to not add in more user error like I did this time around.

Minecraft Monday: Mega Man 3 Sprite Work – The Final Section

Mega Man 3 Title ScreenAfter a week of no progress thanks to a lovely January Flu, I finally got back to work on Mega Man Land this past week. I spent a pretty good amount of time on Thursday and Friday working on the sprite field for Mega Man 3. I mentioned in my post on the Title Screen that I kept screwing up which made that whole part of the project a pain. While I didn’t really have any such screw ups, I did have to make a pretty big change part way through the Robot Master sprites. With the sprites for Mega Man 4, I went in planning on going about them in the order I fight them – as well as including Mega Man with that Robot Master’s weapon and relevant sprites. While this is certainly a complete way of doing it, the resulting sprite field is rather messy – even after cleaning it up by removing the fences. I wanted to take a much more organized approach to Mega Man 3.

With that in mind I started at the left edge of the screen, as before. Again, using the same order that I would tackle the bosses in, I went about it. My goal was to try to keep all the Robot Masters on one row – straight across the bottom of the Stage Select screen. I lined them up with bottom of my buffer between screens, so their feet weren’t quite lined up – Spark Man and Hard Man both extended a bit below, but that wasn’t really that much of an issue. Where I ran into my problem was all the way at the last Robot Master – Needle Man. I had seven already taken care of, and Needle Man was supposed to fit into the last bit of space. When I took a look at his sprite though, it was clear that he wouldn’t fit – he is one wide SOB. So instead of having him extend over into the barrier, or be the only Robot Master on a second row, I took advantage of a Mega Man 3 quirk.

Megaman 3 Stage Select

Mega Man 3 is the only classic series game that has two loops of weaknesses. Normally, the games’ Robot Masters form one big cycle – you just have to pick the one you can beat with just the Buster, and then start the loop. In Mega Man 3 though, that’s a little different. Five Robot Masters have one loop – Top Man, Shadow Man, Spark Man, Magnet Man, and Hard Man – while the remaining three have a second one. That meant I could drop down Snake Man, Gemini Man and Needle Man into a second row and it still would make sense. It did mean undoing my work on Snake Man and Gemini Man’s sprites that I had already made, but that was a little detail. In the end I think it’s the better course. It also opened up enough space to put in Break Man (Proto Man in disguise) as well as a Doc Robot sprite in there, along with a huge Mega Man health bar for flair. Mega Man 3 Sprite Field

As it stands right now, there’s still a bit of work to do. I am trying to figure out how I want to do Mega Man with the weapons this time around, as well as deciding if I want to make Portraits for Doc Robot and Break Man, if there’s even room for them. I also want to put in my dividers between the games. I had originally planned on using Mega Man sprites – particularly him jumping. But I did some more thinking on it, and I think I will end up going with the 1-Up power up as well as the E-Tanks, lined up vertically to create a nice little Wallpaper pattern. So for the next update, I’ll have all the Mega Man sprite work done, plus that little detail, and then it’s on to Mega Man 2, which I’m looking forward to. As I keep going, this OneDrive folder will have the clips I make on the Xbox One:

Minecraft Monday: Mega Man 3 Screens Done

Short post today, since I’ve come down with the classic January cold. Over last week I was able to finish up the Mega Man 3 title screen, despite my best efforts to keep screwing up. I messed up with the M in Man twice, both requiring me to completely re-do the work; and then messed up the A once as well. It’s hard to concentrate when you put on Retsupurae on in the background. The Mega section went pretty smoothly, only one little issue with the A at the end. The only other thing was that I tweaked the colors a little bit. Instead of using two different textures for red, I used pink clay for the normal red tone, and then used the red wool for the dark red. It turned out alright, the sheer scale makes it tough to really tell when zoomed out.

So my plan for this week, once I start to feel better is to go through and do the sprites for the Robot Masters, again in the order that I use to go about beating them. Following that, I want to do a set of Mega Man sprites using the Master weapons, along with a few other details. I’m still nailing down exactly how I want to organize the setup of the sprites, but I want to get started soon. For the most part, the colors should be pretty easy to get right, Top Man might be a little off, but we’ll see. After that, I want to add in some extra details between the Mega Man 3 and Mega Man 4 sets, probably using E-Tanks or Extra Lives – items like that.

For now though, here is the total set – as it exists right now, with both games completed.

Minecraft Monday: Mega Man 3’s Stage Select Falls, Title Screen Putting Up Good Fight

Mega Man 3 Box ArtI mentioned in last week’s update that the Stage Select screen was proving to be a pretty complicated build, thanks to being pretty full of stuff. With Mega Man 4, the Stage Select was really straightforward – the background between the portraits was really simple, and let me use potions of swiftness to finish them really quickly. In Mega Man 3 however, the repeated use of the “Mega Man III” logo throughout the background made me take a different approach.

Instead of going straight across like I did in MM4, I went with instead putting down as many of the “Mega Man III” first, then when they were all put down, and the portraits were completed, I threw on the potion of swiftness and finished out the blue in the background. I don’t really know how much time difference this actually amounted to, mainly because not only did I not actively time my progress with MM4, but also since this is my third full screen project, I have a bit more thought out plan. The total time on the Stage Select for Mega Man 3 was right around eight hours or so – probably a bit more.

In the end, I’m pretty happy with the final product – Snake Man’s green is a little darker than the actual sprite, and for the most part, I went with colors that would probably fit better with a more “realistic” art style. The faces on the Robot Masters – especially on Top Man – in the actual sprites use the same color for the shadows, as they use for the highlights on the red armor. While I could have gone with using the pink clay for both, thanks to the dyed clay options, the light grey clay looks really good next to the white clay as a shadow. It looks a bit more lifelike, and I think it works.

Mega Man 3 Title Screen

Since I finished the Stage Select, I dove right into the Title Screen. I was expecting it to go relatively quickly, mainly because there aren’t much in the way of details. With Mega Man 4, the Title Screen had the large helmet in the lower third, that broke up the black background. In MM3, the whole screen is just black – with the “Mega Man III” at the top, with only “Game Start” and “Pass Word” below it. Everything else is black. It’s good because I can use potions of swiftness, bad because I get bored. The only other issue with the Title Screen is that there is a dark red color used in the “III” and at the top of “Mega” and as I’ve mentioned in the past, there really isn’t a great dark red block. Netherack has sections in it that are dark, but the texture ruins it. So I’m going with just doubling up – red wool and red clay, and hoping it looks good still. After that, it’s on to the sprite field, which I also have a better plan for, in order to make it look a bit more organized. I’ll show what I mean in next week’s update.